On This Page
Scope & Status
Current Retirees & Earned Value
Notional Credits & RTCs
Personal Retirement Accounts
Financing
Professional Review
Scope and Status
The Plan proposes a finite transition from Old-Age and Survivors Insurance retirement financing to a permanent system of individually owned Personal Retirement Accounts. These answers address the principal questions about who is protected, how retirement value is recognized, how the transition is financed, and what the permanent system is designed to accomplish.
What part of Social Security does The Plan address?
The Plan addresses Old-Age and Survivors Insurance retirement financing. Disability Insurance, Medicare, and other federal programs remain outside its scope because they serve different purposes and require separate analysis.
Is this a proposal to privatize all of Social Security?
No. The Plan does not transfer every Social Security function to private institutions. It replaces the OASI retirement-financing structure with a regulated national system of individually owned Personal Retirement Accounts while preserving federal administration, regulation, enforcement, actuarial oversight, and participant protection.
Is The Plan the final position of the Social Security Reform Working Group?
No. It is a developed starting proposal submitted for independent actuarial, economic, legal, administrative, investment, distributional, and legislative review. The Working Group is expected to identify weaknesses, test alternatives, and recommend improvements before broader institutional or legislative consideration.
Why does the Plan change the financing structure rather than merely adjust taxes or benefits?
Conventional reforms can extend solvency while retaining pay-as-you-go financing. The Plan seeks to end the recurring unfunded obligation itself by closing new legacy accruals and moving future retirement financing toward funded ownership.
Help Build the Framework for Permanent Social Security Reform
The Social Security Reform Project welcomes qualified individuals and organizations that can contribute expertise, research, leadership, and institutional credibility. Participants need not agree with every aspect of the current framework, but they should share a commitment to serious, evidence-based reform.
Contribute to the Work
Qualified professionals and institutional representatives may request to participate.
Keep Informed
Receive occasional updates on the Working Group, relevant research, and development of the framework.
Protecting Current Retirees and Earned Value
What happens to people already receiving OASI retirement benefits?
Benefits already in payment remain obligations of the closed legacy OASI system. Scheduled payments continue under the governing transition rules; current beneficiaries are not moved into Personal Retirement Accounts.
What happens to workers age 56 or older when the transition begins?
Age 56 or older is the current governing Plan cutoff. Those workers remain in legacy OASI, and their scheduled benefits remain obligations of the closed transition system. Independent review must test the cutoff for cost, equity, administrative feasibility, and workforce effects.
Do workers younger than 56 lose the retirement value they have already earned?
No. Their retirement value attributable to preimplementation covered work is converted into an individual notional retirement credit recorded by SSA. Postimplementation work continues earning retirement value through notional credits, funded PRA contributions, or both.
How are workers entering covered employment after implementation treated?
They do not enter legacy OASI. From their first covered earnings, they accrue retirement value through notional credits when funded contributions are unavailable or below the certified transition target and through funded PRA contributions when authorized.
Notional Credits and Retirement Transition Certificates
What is a notional retirement credit?
A notional retirement credit is a participant-specific statutory retirement claim recorded by SSA. It preserves preimplementation accrued value and, during transition years when funded PRA contributions do not provide the full certified retirement accrual, records the required additional accrual. It is not a market asset or a Retirement Transition Certificate.
What is a Retirement Transition Certificate (RTC)?
A Retirement Transition Certificate (RTC) is an internal, nonmarketable, inheritable, interest-bearing statutory transition claim used to defer part of an eligible OASI cash payment when transition liquidity requires it. Eligible beneficiaries may elect 25, 50, 75, or 100 percent; no election means cash. RTCs are separate from notional retirement credits and are not PRA assets.
Does retirement accrual stop while funded PRAs are deferred?
No. Retirement accrual continues through notional credits, funded PRA contributions, or both. RTCs do not provide ordinary retirement accrual.
When do funded Personal Retirement Accounts begin?
Funded PRA contributions have no fixed activation year. They begin or increase only when genuine residual capacity remains after higher-priority obligations and required reserves, each of the next two projection years shows at least a 5 percent margin, and the RTC-neutral funding test passes.
How are RTCs redeemed?
Not directly. An RTC is not a PRA asset and cannot be contributed to a PRA. SSA must first redeem and extinguish the RTC; only the resulting cash may then be paid to the beneficiary or deposited into a qualified PRA under the governing rules.
Is the transition permanent?
No. It is a temporary bridge. Final closure occurs only after legacy obligations are ended or satisfied, remaining notional and RTC obligations are extinguished or fully secured, required reserves and tail protections are complete, both OASI payroll taxes terminate permanently, and the funded PRA system can operate independently.
Can an RTC ever be mandatory?
Yes, but only as a residual liquidity backstop. If voluntary RTCs and authorized resources are insufficient to satisfy a binding cash-flow or operating-reserve test, mandatory RTC deferral applies only to the certified amount required, beginning with the highest-net-worth eligible beneficiaries and subject to hardship protection.
Are RTCs backed by the federal government?
Yes. RTC principal and accrued interest are backed by the full faith and credit of the United States. The Plan nevertheless requires the transition cash-flow model to show that RTC obligations can be satisfied from authorized Plan resources without planned Treasury borrowing or general-revenue financing.
Is an RTC a market asset, PRA asset, or Treasury security?
No. An RTC is not a market asset, PRA asset, or Treasury security. SSA must redeem and extinguish the RTC before the resulting cash may be paid to the beneficiary or deposited into a qualified PRA.
Personal Retirement Accounts and Ownership
Who owns the assets in a Personal Retirement Account?
The participant owns the account assets and investment earnings, subject to the national system’s contribution, custody, withdrawal, lifetime-income, and consumer-protection rules. The balance is individually identified and held for the participant’s retirement and protected beneficiaries.
Can the government borrow, invest, spend, or otherwise use PRA assets?
No. Government regulates and protects the system, but it does not own, control, borrow, invest, spend, or otherwise use PRA assets for any governmental purpose.
Who manages the investments?
Qualified providers administer regulated, diversified, low-cost investment options under enforceable fiduciary, custody, disclosure, and reporting standards. Prudent default or lifecycle options protect participants who do not wish to make active investment decisions.
Can remaining PRA assets pass to heirs?
Yes. After the required lifetime-income protection is secured, remaining assets continue as personal property and may pass to designated beneficiaries under the governing rules.
Investment, Lifetime Income, and Risk
Does a funded retirement system eliminate risk?
No retirement system eliminates risk. OASI depends on future taxpayers, demographics, economic growth, and legislation. A funded system adds market and longevity risk but addresses them openly through diversification, long investment horizons, low costs, prudent defaults, fiduciary oversight, actuarial certification, and lifetime-income requirements.
What happens when financial markets decline?
The system is designed for continuous contributions over a working lifetime rather than short-term trading. Diversification and age-appropriate investment strategies reduce concentrated exposure, while lifetime-income and actuarial rules protect the retirement objective. Independent adverse-scenario testing must determine whether the safeguards are sufficient.
How is inflation addressed?
Funded accounts hold financial assets with the potential for long-term growth, and the retirement-income design must be tested for purchasing-power protection. Inflation risk is not assumed away; it is part of the actuarial, investment, and lifetime-income review required before implementation.
Must retirees convert their entire account into an annuity?
No. The Plan requires enough protected lifetime income to satisfy the governing retirement-income standard. A qualified ULIC or actuarially equivalent regulated product provides the protected lifetime-income and applicable family-protection package. Assets not required for protected lifetime income remain personal property under the governing payout and inheritance rules.
What is the normal full retirement age?
67. There is no automatic age-68 rule. A later change may occur only prospectively for future cohorts through the Longevity Stabilizer.
Financing and the Mature System
Will the transition raise the mandatory OASI payroll-financing rate?
No. The combined mandatory payroll-financing rate cannot exceed the existing 10.6 percent OASI rate, and the Plan cannot impose a separate mandatory PRA contribution on top of that ceiling.
Does the transition use federal borrowing or general revenue?
No. External federal cash borrowing and general-revenue transfers are prohibited. Transition obligations must be met from authorized OASI resources and permitted reserves under the governing priority rules.
What receives priority during the transition?
Authorized resources first pay scheduled benefits, required transition obligations, administration, and required reserves. Funded PRA contributions begin or increase only after higher-priority commitments remain protected, the two-year 5 percent buffer is satisfied, and the RTC-neutral funding test passes.
Why is the proposed permanent system structurally different from PAYGO?
In the mature system, each generation accumulates assets to finance its own retirement rather than renewing an open-ended claim on later workers. Prospective stabilizers and actuarial oversight may adjust future parameters, but accrued assets cannot be converted back into an unfunded pay-as-you-go promise.
How much additional take-home pay is the Plan designed to produce?
At final closure, both OASI tax obligations end and the employer’s former 5.3 percent OASI contribution becomes employee compensation. For ordinary earnings within applicable limits, the retirement-financing conversion produces a pre-income-tax compensation/cash-flow difference equal to 10.6 percent minus the participant’s IACR. After-tax take-home pay depends on ordinary tax treatment.
What happens to mandatory retirement financing above the median-wage cap?
The permanent system does not use the former median-wage cap. The normal mandatory contribution base is 1.50 times the Reference Full-Time Median Wage; 1.75 times is the first certified fallback, after which the base may ratchet toward the Reference OASI Taxable Maximum if required.
What is the mature mandatory PRA contribution target?
There is no single permanent PRA contribution rate. After OASI closure, each participant has an individualized employee-only all-in Individual Adequacy Contribution Rate (IACR), capped at 10.6 percent of PRA Reference Earnings up to the applicable contribution base.
Professional Review and Participation
Who will evaluate the proposal?
The Social Security Reform Working Group is intended to bring together actuaries, economists, attorneys, investment and retirement professionals, policymakers, researchers, business leaders, and institutions capable of testing the Plan’s assumptions, implementation, distributional effects, and practical feasibility.
Are the governing Technical Specifications for Scoring public?
No. The governing Technical Specifications for Scoring, integrated model, and related working materials are proprietary controlled-review materials. They are provided only within approved Working Group or specifically authorized professional-review arrangements that include the applicable confidentiality requirements.
What materials are available to the public?
The public website provides The Plan overview, The Goal, The Transition, this FAQ, The Plan — Full Text in native online text and downloadable PDF form, and a public Technical Specifications for Scoring explanatory page describing the TSS’s purpose and restricted-access status. Additional approved resources, including Benefits of the plan and International PRAs, may be published when completed and approved.
How can a qualified professional request participation?
Use a Request to Join button or select Request to Join on the Contact page. Both routes open the same unified inquiry form. Applicants should identify their professional role, relevant experience, and the contribution they could make to the Working Group.
How should media or institutional inquiries be submitted?
Use the Contact page and select Media Inquiry, Professional or Institutional Inquiry, Presentation Request, or Technical Inquiry. Media requests are identified separately so time-sensitive communications can receive priority.
Continue With the Governing Public Materials
The Plan
Review the integrated public overview of the destination, transition, and binding fiscal discipline.
The Transition
Examine participant protection, notional retirement credits, Retirement Transition Certificates, fiscal priorities, PRA activation, stabilizers, and closure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Practical Questions About The Plan.
Answers to common questions about the scope, transition, financing, Personal Retirement Accounts, participant protections, and professional review of The Plan.